+ Olive







We've been making it cool to WEAR SECONDHAND CLOTHING since 2022


01. The Vibes

What started as a clothing boutique quickly turned into the spot to find gently used, sustainable, high end fashion, books, plants, and records. As our world begins shifting to a more sustainable future, we recognized the need to stop contributing to fast fashion, and instead give your fave quality items a second, third or fourth chance at life.

We already have everything we need; there's no need to buy new. 

Sunny + Olive

02. the owner

Get to know

03. the why

Used clothing, plants, records, books, good music, good vibes, good people, what could be better?

The goal of Sunny + Olive is to give people a place to be themselves while helping to save the planet.

We carry women's clothing in sizes xxs through 5x. Jeans, sweaters, dresses, skirts, and more. From vintage items to today's current trends. 

The Vibes

Step into our oasis

Never been thrifting before or it overwhelms you? Our shop is small and easy to navigate making it the perfect place for baby thrifters!

We are located in Milton's historical district just down the street from the old Milton College campus. Our building is just over 130 years old with unique original features.  

We are surrounded by other incredible small businesses like Sharla's Coffee and Bake Stop, home decor and vintage sellers Hattie & Elsie, another consignment shop, Corner Closet; and Farmhouse Finds. We are always growing!

the owner

Looking for something to eat? Natalie's has the best fries, The Ice ShanTea has incredible pizza and boba, and Cafe 26 is a short drive from us and offering delicious cafe food. We also have two amazing wineries just a quick 2 minute drive away!

We hope you can find something you absolutely love, and if not we hope you enjoy the vibes we work so hard to create! We never want anyone to feel left out or uncomfortable. No judgement, just good vibes.



Never in my wildest dreams did I think I'd own a thrift store. I think back to the days when Macklemore's "Thrift Shop" song was overplayed on the radio and as much as I loved the song AND thrifting, I never thought I'd be here, running my very own thrift shop and poppin tags.

My perfect day consists of books, thrift shops, plants, and an amazing cup of coffee. I'm so blessed that my lil ol' shop in the heart of Milton offers all of those things with a coffee stop just down the road!

Thrifting has allowed me to find my own individual style, learn to accept my body, and realize just how arbitrary clothing sizes are. I absolutely LOVE reusing clothing and finding new, awesome ways to style it. I'm beyond excited to help other women do the same. 

We are all such unique individuals and our sense of style should clearly reflect that. Thrifting allows you to try things you normally wouldn't (without breaking the bank). It allows you to be creative, show off your fashion talents, help save the world, and so much more. Big fan, my friends, big fan. 


The Why

The Why

Sunny + Olive originally opened in 2022 as a clothing and accessories boutique.

I get asked a lot, "why did you make the switch?"

The simple answer is, I'm not a boutique owner.

The nitty gritty answer: I never felt connected to the boutique side of things. I didn't have a "why". I was just going through the motions because that's what was expected of me as a store owner.  I didn't enjoy shopping for new merchandise, or vetting vendors, tagging and pricing a bajillion of the same item, trying to sell on social media, carrying the same things that every other boutique carried, etc. Believe me, I know what being passionate about something feels like, and I wasn't passionate about being a boutique owner. 

I am, however, passionate about helping women learn to love themselves and their bodies and teaching them that it's okay to wear whatever the hell you want that makes you feel good.

I'm also very passionate about finding the needle in a haystack when it comes to thrifting quality clothing ... and figuring out what my own personal style is ... and saving the Earth ... and books ... and growing plants ... and music ... and good vibes. 

So I decided to do something that felt like ME and something that made ME happy which allows me to better take care of others. 

I wanted to create a place that spread good vibes, that accepted anyone and everyone, that helped people learn to love themselves, that helps save the Earth, and that prides itself on good fashion at affordable prices. 

So welcome to Sunny + Olive 2.0: The Resale Shop

Back to home


Located at

649 College St. Milton, WI 53563

Store hours

Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 10-5 p
Wednesday: 10-5 pm
Thursday: 10-5 pm
Friday: 10-5 pm
Saturday: 10-5 pm
Sunday: 11-3 pm

How to consign

Store Hours + Location

How to consign

Bring your gently used, name brand clothing, accessories, and books to Sunny + Olive anytime we're open and we'll sell them for you!

We hang on to your items for 60 days and whenever an item sells, you'll receive 50% of the sales price. 

After 60 days, whatever is left will be given back to you, or donated to a women's shelter or non-profit.

It's that easy!


Frequently Asked questions

Q. Do you need an appointment?

A. No appointment needed! Stop in whenever we're open.

Q. What items are you accepting?

A. Gently used, high quality, name brand clothing, accessories, bags, and books!
Follow us on Social Media to see specifics


Frequently Asked questions

Q. How do we get paid?

A. Once an item sells, 50% of the sales price is added to your account. Come in anytime to redeem for cash or in store credit.

Q. Will you notify us that our 60 days is up?

A. We do not keep track of your time with us. I recommend adding the date to your calendar!


Frequently Asked questions

Q. Where do you donate items that haven't sold?

A. We donate your items to a variety of nonprofits like women's shelters, domestic abuse shelters, schools, and more.
If you have suggestions of places to donate, please let us know!

Back to home



The best way to contact us is using the form below (email) or messaging us on social media.

Please give us 24 hours to respond (48 hours if weekend or holiday)

Questions, concerns, or want to let us know how we're doing?

We'll be in contact soon!

In the meantime, be sure to check out our social media to stay up to date on whats going on!

Have a fantastic day :)

Thanks so much for your message!