The 6 Best Consignment Shops Near Madison & Chicago — And Why Shoppers are Flocking to Milton, WI
Are you in need of high-quality secondhand finds? If so, you’re in the right place. We’ve put together this list of six must-visit consignment shops in the Chicago and Madision regions. Let’s dive in!
1. Sunny & Olive in Milton, WI
Looking for trendy, affordable, and quality secondhand finds? Sunny & Olive carries everything from clothing and accessories to books and more. We’re all about size inclusivity and making space for everyone, which is why you’ll also find a “mens” section in our store.
And here’s something we’re extra proud of: we’re 100% women-owned and run. Plus, all the small businesses we feature in-store are women-owned, too. From handmade jewelry and stickers to scrunchies, candles, soap, and more, you’ll find plenty of new treasures created with love by local makers.
With 40+ five-star reviews, you’re sure to have a quality experience at our shop! Shoppers from all over the Midwest flock to our store for great deals on amazing pieces.
Fun bonus: our friendly staff is always making entertaining Reels on the ‘gram.
613 W Madison Ave.
Milton, WI 53563
2. Stillgood’s in Madison, WI
You’ll find gently worn designer, contemporary, and vintage clothing at Stillgood’s. Shoppers note the friendly staff, great selection of clothes, and top-notch atmosphere.
1521 Williamson St.
Madison, WI 53703
3. Simply Savvy in Middleton, WI
Simply Savvy carries everything from men & women’s clothing to housewares, furniture, home decor, and more. The friendly staff is extremely knowledgeable, kind, and helpful. Additionally, shoppers find the store to be beautifully organized and clean.
6333 University Ave. Ste 102
Middleton, WI 53562
4. Classy Closet Consignment in Evanston, IL
Classy Closet Consignment is a well-regarded shop for new, used, and vintage designer clothing for both men and women. The store is known for its affordable and sustainable focus, as well as great customer service. Shoppers say the employees are kind and the store is well-organized.
701 Washington St.
Evanston, Il 60202
5. Mr. & Mrs. DIGZ in Chicago, IL
Mr. & Mrs. DIGZ is Chicago’s premiere source for designer and luxury resale at lower prices. The store buys items on the spot. Accepted items include handbags, shoes, clothing, jewelry, sunglasses, belts, and accessories for both men and women. Patrons note that the owner is helpful, knowledgeable, and patient. Shopping available online.
6. Elliot Consignment in Chicago, IL
Elliot Consignment is family owned and operated since 1996 with two locations in Chicago. Over the decades, this store has kept hundreds of clothing items out of landfills and into the wardrobes of happy shoppers. Customer reviews note a wonderful selection of clothing, purses, shoes, backpacks, and other high-end, gently worn items.
2465 N. Lincoln Ave.
Chicago, IL 60614
and
3015 N. Broadway
Chicago, IL 60657
Get the Best Deals at Sunny & Olive
Looking for high-quality items at a lower price? Subscribe to Sunny & Olive’s email list for 10% off your next purchase. The sign up form is located on our home page.